Family Dynamics: A Foundation For

Parent Alienation



Interpersonal Family Dynamics

Are Influential
In Development Of Alienation


Find an Attorney FREE Now
Need A Lawyer? Click Here To Find One Near You


Family Dynamics Are Often Ignored With Alienation

When Dr. Richard Gardner introduced the concept of Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) he inadvertently created a storm of controversy among mental health professionals that has

resulted in much confusion and misunderstandings.  The argument whether the problem meets the medical standards of a "Syndrome"  has clouded the issue and led some to question the basic validity of "Parental Alienation." The courts and child advocates are perhaps more skeptical  because of the dueling and often misconstrued accusations made in the courts and with social service agencies.  Whether or not Alienation can be considered a "Syndrome" the symptoms, behavior, and results are very, very real.  And, although the results of Alienation are extremely destructive they are often misunderstood or ignored by professionals.  Pre-alienation family dynamics play a significant role and need to be carefully examined by professionals concerned about the child's best interests.

Regardless of the terminology, the Alienation of a child from one parent in some toxic divorces is real.  But, because of the uniqueness of family dynamics it is often very difficult to determine how it happened and the degree of malignancy it has reached by the time professionals become involved.  Extreme Parental Alienation that approaches the "Syndrome" criteria defined by Gardner is relatively rare and all three parties to the divorce usually play a role. 

Personalty Disorders And PAS

The Alienator almost always has one or more personality disorders which enables them to undertake such an unconscionable assault against both the other parent and the child.

Click on the link for more information

Please note that in the remainder of this and its associated pages I have borrowed heavily from an article published in "The Family Court  Review"  entitled THE ALIENATED CHILD: A Reformulation of Parental Alienation Syndrome by  Joan B. Kelly and Jane R. Johnston

Gardner described Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) as a disorder in the child that has generated both an enthusiastic acceptance and a strong negative response.  It is the child's campaign of unjustified denigration against a parent that results from the combination of two contributing factors:  the programming or brainwashing by one parent and the child’s own willing contributions to the vilification of the target.  He notes that the indoctrinating parent is usually the mother and that false allegations of sexual abuse are common.  Kelly and Johnston contend, though, that the abuse does not meet the standards of a "syndrome" so they are more concerned with the actual alienation process. 

Although many parents participate in alienating behavior only a small percentage of children become alienated.  There are a number of contributing factors and conditions that play into the process of alienation. And family dynamics play a significant role in determining the success of an alienation campaign.

The Family

1. A Narcissistic Response

Prior to separation, some parents use the child and place them right in the middle of the marital conflict. Typically, school-age children are torn between parents because they are pressured to take sides in the toxic relationship, be a messenger between parents, rescue a parent's psyche, and exclude or be punitive toward a parent. In some cases a parent actually resents the children because they replaced the spouse at birth in terms of affection and attachment. These are examples of the family dynamics that are relevant to alienation.

The alienator parent commonly experiences a deep narcissistic injury, such as complete abandonment, which results in profound humiliation and rage. This narcissistic response frequently results in response to the reasons for and the manner in which the separation occurred.  For example, There may be a vehement narcissistic response if there was no opportunity for the alienator to become emotional prepared, if there was the presence of a lover, if the spouse decided to pursue a gay lifestyle, if the residence was emptied of furnishings and children without warning, etc.

Even in the absence of a sudden, traumatic separation the rage of a narcissist spouse trigger vindictiveness, revenge, and a blurring of the boundaries between parent and child where the alienator initiates alliance with the child expressed as an "us" against him or her in all routine matters.

Narcissism

Narcissism may be the most common and dangerous personality disorder associated with Parental Alienation.  Click here for more about Narcissism.

2. Litigation and Conflicted Divorce

Divorces characterized by bitter and protracted legal proceedings, continued verbal and/or physical aggression after separation, unsubstantiated allegations and counterallegations of child abuse, neglect, or parental lack of interest are also more likely to result in alienation in the child.

They are inappropriately treated as adults in matters from which they should be insulated.  They are often used as confidants about legal and financial matters, are given too great a choice about visiting the nonresidential parent, and are exposed to repeated parental denigration of one or both parents. The intensity of the conflict, its unrelenting consistency, the polarization of the child and the extended family and the parents inability to address the child's needs together can create an intolerable degree of anguish, tension, and anger in the child.

One psychological survival  response by the child is to relieve the unbearable stress  by rejecting the “bad" parent and ceasing all contact.

3. New Partners, Extended Families, and Advocates

A new partner can have a sudden and dramatic impact on the family dynamics in alienation. New partners, particularly those perceived to be responsible for the breakup of the marriage, can serve as a lightning rod for rage about the divorce, and children in such situations often are faced with stark loyalty conflicts and hard choices.  They might feel betrayed by the discovery of a new partner and experience a sense of abandonment by the parent as well as resentment for both the parent and new partner.

The courts and its officers ( lawyers ) often severely exacerbate the problem in extended high conflict divorces.  Because cases in which children refuse to visit often  are accompanied by allegations of emotional or physical abuse, neglect, or parental lack of interest in the child, most often framed and litigated in highly inflammatory language, professionals tend to become polarized themselves and take absolute, rigid viewpoints supporting their clients.

Sometimes,  the attorneys and other professionals fail to recognize the problem and have been known to collaborate to maintain the staus quo because the child seems happy with the alienator and a change would actually be harmful.  See the article on why alienated parents lose in court.

When therapists selected for the child have no knowledge of the child alienation processes or collaborative efforts needed to assist such children and families, considerable harm can be done in addressing the child’s rage and the unwarranted rejection of the parent. 


Read about the Alienator's Role In The Process

Read Aout The Targeted Parent's Role In The Family Dynamics Leading To Alienation.

Read About The Child's Role In The Family Dynamics Leading To Alienation.



 


Table of Contents

Alienator Personality Types And Parental Alienation
Alienator Personality Types Perpetrate Parental Alienation
Personality Disorders And Parental Alienation
Personality Disorders Play A Significant Role In Parent Alienation
Convergent Emotional Disorders
The convergence Of Emotional Disorders Can Be The Key To Parental Alienation
Family Dynamics' Significance In Alienation
Family Dynamics And Individual Personalities Are Significant Factors In Parental Alienation
Child Advocacy Is Failing Families Battling Against Parental Alienation
Child Advocacy is Is Failing Families Battling Against Parental Alienation
Therapeutic Intervention In Parental Alienation
Early Therapeutic Intervention May Prevent Parent Alienation
Parental Alienation Destroyed My Family
A Carefully Executed Plan Of Parental Alienation Destroyed My Family
Comments Form
Share Your Story And Comments Of Your Experience With Parent Alienation